Feet hurt? Visit our storefront for your FREE iStep foot analysis today!

The Shoe Fits

We'd love to hear from you.


The Shoe Fits Comfort Shoes & Boots
691 Route 25A
Miller Place, NY 11764

Store Hours:
Mon-Fri: 10am-6pm
Sat: 10am-5pm
Sun: Closed

Phone: (631) 209-0299
Fax: (631) 209-0093

Questions or comments? Email us.


Frequently Asked Questions
If the shoe fits, should I buy it in every color?... Yes!

Does The Shoe Fits do shoe repair?

Yes, we have a full repair facility that offers semi-traditional repair services. Our repair technicians operate on a Mon-Fri schedule, and the typical turnaround is 7 days. All repairs are done on premises. A deposit or pre-payment is required on all repairs at the time of drop off. For pricing or specific repair questions, please stop in.

For specialty repair of Red Wing shoes and boots, please visit www.RedWingRepairUSA.com

Do you repair shoes that are not from your store?

Yes. We repair shoes from other stores, however, some shoes are unrepairable. We must see a shoe before we can guarantee a repair.

What methods of payment do you accept?

Our storefront accepts cash, personal check, debit, and credit (Amex, Visa, Mastercard, Discover). We also accept industrial subsidies for Red Wing shoes and boots.

What is your return policy?

Returns or exchanges of unworn merchandise in original packaging must be made within 30 days for a full refund or store credit. NO CASH REFUNDS will be distributed. Returns on special order items are subject to a $10 restocking fee per pair on non in-stock items and store credit only. Clearance items are final sale.

How do I place a special order?

We accept special orders for items that we do not currently have available or styles/colors that we do not stock, based on manufacturer availability. All special orders must be paid in full at the time of ordering. Special orders generally come in within 1-2 weeks. Returns on special orders may incur a $10 per pair restocking fee and are valid for store credit only.

Can I order from your website?

At this time, we are not an online retailer. If you have purchased from us before or are interested in one of our styles, we would be happy to take an order over the phone and ship it to you.

What brands do you carry?

We are an authorized retailer of: Red Wing Shoes, Irish Setter, New Balance, Dunham, Merrell, Dansko, NAOT, Waldlaufer, Keen, Sebago, Florsheim, SAS, Muck, Aetrex, Clarks, Cobb Hill, Haflinger, Cloud Nine Sheepskin, Vionic/Orthaheel, Toe Warmers, Wanderlust, Arcopedico, and Aravon.

To view a selection of our current line, please select from the Men's or Women's tab in the top menu bar.

Do you make custom orthotics?

No. We do not make custom orthotics, however we do carry a premium line of ready-made orthotics. These doctor-recommended inserts are available in several styles and sizes. A member of our trained staff will complete an iStep foot analysis to recommend the best Aetrex Lynco orthotic for your feet. For more information on Aetrex and foot health, visit our shoe blog.

If you have custom orthotics from your podiatrist or orthopedist, our line of comfort shoes and boots accommodates orthotics, braces, and interior lifts. One of our customer care professionals will assist you in finding the right shoe for your orthotic at the time of your visit.